Milk-Bone vs Single-Ingredient Dog Treats

Today we're starting a series of "This or That," reviewing the ingredients in many of today's popular dog biscuits. We'll take on various proteins and have a discussion on what may be lurking in your best pal's treats. 

We kick it off with Milk-Bone original dog biscuits, which features "beef" as its main flavor (We're not listing beef as the biscuit's actual protein, because it's unclear from the Milk-Bone website what the actual protein is... it's just listed as "meat," followed by "beef fat" and "natural flavor"). 

Ingredients in Milk-Bone Original Biscuits, according to the Milk-Bone website: Ground Whole Wheat, Wheat Flour, Meat And Bone Meal, Milk, Beef Fat (preserved With Bha/bht And Mixed Tocopherols), Salt, Natural Flavor, Dicalcium Phosphate, Calcium Carbonate, Malted Barley Flour, Sodium Metabisulfite (used As A Preservative), Minerals (ferrous Sulfate, Zinc Oxide, Manganous Oxide, Copper Sulfate, Calcium Iodate, Sodium Selenite), Vitamins (vitamin E Supplement, Niacin Supplement, Vitamin A Supplement, D-calcium Pantothenate, Riboflavin Supplement, Pyridoxine Hydrochloride, Vitamin D3 Supplement, Folic Acid, Biotin, Vitamin B12 Supplement), Brewers Dried Yeast, Bha (used As A Preservative), Mixed Tocopherols (used As A Preservative), Rosemary Extract.

Do any of the ingredients surprise you? 

As dog owners, we want the best for our pets, especially when it comes to their diet. When it comes to dog treats, it’s important to know exactly what’s in the products we’re giving our dogs. For years, Milk-Bone has been a popular choice for dog treats, but there’s a growing trend towards single-ingredient dog treats. What’s the difference between the two, and what should you be considering when choosing which dog biscuit is right for your dog?

What’s in a Milk-Bone Dog Biscuit?

Milk-Bone biscuits are one of the most recognizable dog treat brands, known for their crunchy texture and variety of flavors. The ingredients in these treats are generally designed to be appealing and nutritious, though not all of them are as natural or simple as you might expect.

Typical ingredients in Milk-Bone dog biscuits (they have an extensive treats line) include:

1. Wheat Flour: This is the primary ingredient in Milk-Bone treats, providing structure and texture. Wheat is a common ingredient in many commercial dog foods and treats, though some dogs may be sensitive or allergic to gluten.

2. Chicken by-product meal: A blend of rendered chicken parts that might not be as appetizing or nutritious as whole chicken. By-products often include less-desirable parts of the animal.

3. Animal Fats: These fats are used to enhance flavor and improve the treat’s texture. While they can be a good source of energy for dogs, it’s important to note that not all fats are created equal—some animal fats can be high in saturated fat.

4. Cornmeal: Another filler ingredient that contributes to the texture. Cornmeal is a common ingredient in dog food, but some owners avoid it due to concerns about its digestibility or its potential to cause allergies in sensitive dogs.

5. Salt: Like in human snacks, salt is used to enhance flavor. Too much salt can lead to health problems.

6. Preservatives and artificial colors: To extend shelf life and make the treats more visually appealing, Milk-Bone biscuits often contain preservatives like BHT (butylated hydroxytoluene) and artificial colors, which many pet owners preferring to avoid additives in their dog’s food.

While Milk-Bone dog biscuits offer a convenient, mass-produced option that can be found in most pet stores, many pet owners are now leaning toward simpler, more natural treats, which leads us to single-ingredient dog treats.

What’s in Single-Ingredient Dog Treats?

As the name suggests, single-ingredient dog treats focus on providing just one, whole food item, without the added fillers, artificial preservatives, or other additives commonly found in processed treats. These treats are often closer to what dogs would consume in the wild and can be a great option for owners who want to limit the number of ingredients in their dog’s diet.

Some popular single-ingredient dog treats include:

1. Dehydrated or Freeze-Dried Meat: Whether it’s chicken, beef, duck, turkey, or fish, these treats offer a pure protein source that’s easy to digest and rich in essential nutrients. Single-ingredient meat treats are often high in protein and low in fat, making them an excellent choice for dogs with sensitivities or specific dietary needs.

2. Sweet Potato: Dried or dehydrated sweet potato slices are another common single-ingredient treat. These treats are high in fiber, vitamins (especially vitamin A), and minerals like potassium. They’re a great option for dogs that need a gentle, hypoallergenic snack.

3. Liver: Dehydrated liver, whether from beef, chicken, duck or other animals, is packed with nutrients, including iron, vitamin A, and B vitamins. Liver treats are often a favorite among dogs due to their strong aroma and rich flavor.

4. Carrots: Raw or dehydrated carrots make a crunchy and low-calorie treat that’s packed with beta-carotene, fiber, and antioxidants. These can be a healthy option for dogs who enjoy crunchy snacks.

5. Fish Skin: Dried fish skin treats offer omega-3 fatty acids that help with skin and coat health. Plus, they’re a natural source of protein and essential minerals.

One of the major benefits of single-ingredient dog treats is the simplicity of the ingredients. You know exactly what your dog is consuming, which can be especially important for dogs with food allergies or sensitivities. Single-ingredient treats are also often more natural, free from artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives.

Milk-Bone vs. Single-Ingredient Treats: Which Is Better for Your Dog?

When comparing Milk-Bone dog biscuits to single-ingredient dog treats, the main difference lies in the ingredient list and how processed the treats are. Milk-Bones are a more traditional, mass-produced option that balances flavor, nutrition, and convenience. However, they often contain fillers, preservatives, and by-products that some pet owners might want to avoid.

Single-ingredient dog treats, on the other hand, are usually more straightforward and natural. They tend to be less processed and provide a single, high-quality source of nutrition. For dogs with food sensitivities or those needing a simpler diet, single-ingredient dog treats are a great option.

Choosing the right dog treat depends on your dog’s health needs, preferences, and any allergies or sensitivities they may have. While Milk-Bone dog biscuits are a popular and widely available choice, single-ingredient dog treats often offer a more natural and straightforward alternative. As always, it’s important to consult your veterinarian if you have concerns about what’s best for your dog’s diet.